Showing posts with label intelligent design. Show all posts
Showing posts with label intelligent design. Show all posts

Friday, May 12, 2017

Species Evolve, So Why Can't Our Mindset?

After hundreds of years of research, it has been made extremely clear that Darwin's theory of Evolution is viable.  However, it is still not uncommon in the United States to come across someone who considers it to be unreasonable.  The longer you argue with them, the more incapable you become of convincing them that Darwin is correct.  Their creationist ideals have been instilled in them over generations, so it is only natural that they struggle to accept another concept.  But why, exactly is this natural?  There have been countless court cases involving evolution versus creationism, and yet no matter how many times a ruling is made, another court case turns up debating the exact same issue. This is a long-discussed issue that has yet to be solved.

Perhaps the most well-known case of evolution is the Scopes Monkey Trial, more officially known as the State of Tennessee v. John Thomas Scopes.  The case took place in 1925, and quickly became a nation-wide phenomenon as people tuned into the radio to hear the event transpire.  The case essentially attempted to charge John Thomas Scopes with a misdemeanor for teaching evolution in a classroom that was intended to be strictly creationist.  The court's extremely Christian attitude found Scopes to be guilty, and he was charged with a crime (which was overturned two years later). However, the intense outcry from the other end of the evolutionary spectrum was enough to lead to the death of the prosecutor, William Jennings Bryan, just a number of days later.  In this case, both sides of the argument fought so intensely that both the defendant AND prosecutor got hurt.  Although in this situation creationism was preferred, that was not always the case.

In 1968, the case of Epperson v. Arkansas, which had a similar background to the Scopes Monkey Trial, overthrew a statute which prohibited teaching evolution.  However, although the outcome for this case was different, it still was not ruled on the basis of fact.  The court's ruling made the claim that according to the First Amendment to the Constitution, teaching cannot be catered to the needs of a specific religion, and by extension, cannot exclude things.  Although this was a step in the right direction for Darwin's theory, the ruling was not made simply because creationism is an unproven theory; it was more founded on the concept of freedom of speech.  In order to properly teach Darwin's theory it must be regarded as fact, therefore the ruling made it a flawed lesson.

Although there have been countless cases on evolution, it is best to focus on those more spread out, in order to properly examine the lack of change throughout generations of learning--similar to the studying of evolution itself.  Therefore, it is best to focus on a more modern case now (as modern as creationism can get)- the case of Kitzmiller v. Dover (2005).  In this case, the District Court Judge ruled to destroy the intelligent design policy in the Dover School District, which forced teachers to explore the "gaps in the theory of Evolution" and offer more "theories" like intelligent design, which is, for all intents and purposes, creationism.  In this case, a large number of people refused to back off on the idea of using the book Of Pandas and People in an attempt to not abandon their literal interpretations of the Bible when teaching students.  The actual teachers at the school, who knew better, fought their hardest to disallow the teaching of an unconfirmed "theory."  In this situation, although it was extremely modern, creationists still refused to change their opinion, despite the facts. This, of course, was the  case for the biology teachers, as well, but they had years of factual research to back up their extremely legitimate theory.  Even eighty years after the Scopes Monkey Trial, people still refused to change their minds.

So where does this stubborn unwillingness to adapt to the facts come from? After many studies, scientists argue the idea of cognitive dissonance, in which people struggle with the concept of balancing two opposing ideas.  It is because of this that no matter what they hear, no  matter how factual it may be, people refuse to change their mind.  Because of this natural inclination to act headstrong when learning, people intentionally block out information that they consider to be wrong. They use a tactic known as motivated reasoning, in which they actively seek out agreeable information.  It is because of selective exposure like this that people tend to stay within their own realm.  It is from this that the well-known media bias stems as well.  The willingness of the public to search out news sources that they agree with is what fuels the revenue of such companies, like the New York Times, Fox News, and others.  Over time, people find themselves far more certain in their beliefs, whether factual or not, due to the news sources they access.  It additionally comes from the people who argue with them, as they eventually choose to just block them out in an attempt to remain correct.  This is unfortunately the case with creationists; no matter how much the world changes, they will still find themselves sticking to their guns about what is true and what is not, even if there is not factual evidence to back up their beliefs.

Thursday, May 11, 2017

Teaching Evolution: A History

The teaching of evolution in public schools has long been a controversial issue in the United States. Scientists have long clashed with creationists over presenting unbiased information on the proven scientific fact of the theory of evolution. In this post, I am going to show you a history of how evolution has been taught in schools, and the court cases that helped shape this law

In Darwin's Day

When Charles Darwin published his book, On the Origin of Species, the public response was mixed. Darwin had the unfortunate luck of publishing his book at the same time that a new movement of Evangelist Christianity was spreading through the United States. Prominent evangelist preachers, such as Dwight L. Moody quickly condemned Darwin's text, calling it contrary to the teachings of Bible. Public opinion, particularly in southern states where evangelists were more prevalent, swung generally against teaching this new theory of evolution in schools.

The Butler Act and the Scopes Monkey Trial (1925)

A scene from Inherit the Wind about the Scopes Money Trail
In response to these beliefs, many states created laws that actively prevented the teaching of Evolution in schools. The Butler Act was a Tennessee law passed in 1925 that outlawed public school teachers contradicting in any way the creation story from the bible, as well as teaching that "man is descended from a lower order of animal". This law was eventually challenged by the ACLU, following the arrest of the high school teacher John Scopes under the law. This led to the highly controversial case referred to as the Scopes Monkey Trial. Following days of contentious, incredibly publicized and sensationalized debate, the jury ruled in favor of the law, upholding John Scopes' arrest. The issue of teaching evolution quietly died, with many (mostly southern) states passing similar laws. Evolution, for the most part, would not be taught in public schools for the next 40 years.

Epperson v Arkansas (1968)

Susan Epperson, the brave teacher who
put providing a good education above
her own freedom!


The next time that the issue of teaching of evolution would come back into public view was the Supreme Court case of Epperson v. Arkansas. Susan Epperson was a high school teacher in Arkansas who sued the Arkansas legislature over a law that forbid teachers from teaching evolution, or even from using textbooks that taught evolution. Epperson argued that the Arkansas law limited her First Amendment rights. In a landmark decision, the Supreme Court decided that the Arkansas law violated the Establishment Clause of the Constitution (the part that prevents the government from establishing a state religion). The court decided that, because the law was clearly based on the beliefs of fundamentalist christians, it was unduly helping one particular religious sect, and was therefore unconstitutional.

Edwards v Aguillard (1987)

Pictured: A balance, like the Louisiana law tried to make
between evolution and creationism education in schools
No longer allowed to ban evolution education outright, anti-evolution advocates switched tactics. Now, many conservative groups attempted to chip away at evolution education by instead framing the issue as a controversy between two equally valid ideas: evolution vs. creationism. Now, quite obviously, evolution and creationism are not equal ideas, as one is a scientific argument and one is based in religion. However, by branding the issue like this, anti-evolution advocates sought to get around the decision of Epperson v Arkansas and to allow creationsim to be taught in public schools. This is also where the idea of "Teach the Controversy" comes from, that schools should present 'both sides' of this 'controversial' issue, and allow students to decide for themselves. This is problematic in the case of evolution, as 'teaching the controversy' presents the two ideas as equally scientifically valid, and promotes the teaching of religious principles in public schools.

This rebranding led to the creation of a Louisiana law, the "Balanced Treatment for Creation Science and Evolution Science in Schools Act", that prohibited the teaching of evolution in public schools, unless such teaching was accompanied by teaching of 'creation science' along side it. The Supreme Court ultimately saw through this rebranding, stating that the law was clearly in violation of the establishment clause, as it required teachers to teach creationism, a religious doctrine, in public schools.

Kiltzmeier v Dover Area School District (2005)

Anti-evolution advocates were stuck. They wanted creationism taught in schools, but had no way of getting around the pesky separation of Church and State. The answer came in the form of a new phrase, fresh off the presses of the conservative think tank the Discovery Institute: Intelligent Design (ID). ID, in essence, is creationism hiding as pseudoscience. A textbook, Of Pandas and People, was quickly written by creation scientist Percival Davis, presenting a number of pseudoscientific justifications for the idea that many things in nature show signs of being far too complex to have occurred naturally, and instead could only have been designed by some sort of creator. These ideas, of course, can be directly debunked by any evolutionary scientist. ID was a clever tactic, which built off of the ideas defeated in Edwards v Aguillard by presenting a debate between the 'equally valid', now both scientific ideas of evolution vs. intelligent design.

A lawsuit appeared in the Dover Area School District, after school district officials required teachers to read a statement about how ID was a logical, scientific alternative to the theory of evolution which the statement described as having holes and flaws. The case came before a federal judge who, over several days, took testimony from both biologists and creation scientists. In the end, the judge decided that ID was pointedly NOT SCIENCE, and that it was merely another attempt to allow creationism to be taught in public schools.
A pseudoscientific textbook that teaches intelligent design

The Story Today


Today, two states have laws on the books that permit creationism to be taught in public schools. Despite the years of drawn out legal battles, evolution is not taught everywhere throughout the United States. Even beyond the legal battles, there is not any good way to tell what is actually being taught in science classes throughout this country. Many schools probably continue to flaunt settled law to push religious arguments on students in public schools. Because of these issues of education, many adults in this country still refuse to accept the undeniable scientific truth that is Evolution. As laws change, and as our society progresses, hopefully our evolution education can improve. As our education improves, perhaps our societal views on evolution will start to improve as well.

For more info check out:
  • This more in-depth timeline of the history of evolution education in this country!
  • This article from the NCSE on evolution education!
  • This pew research article on the current laws on evolution education, state by state.